Best Flagstaff Homes Reality

Best Flagstaff Homes Realty

Best Flagstaff Homes Realty isn’t your typical real estate team. We pride ourselves on handling every aspect of the real estate market. From residential to commercial; luxury homes to starter homes, Best Flagstaff Homes Realty is the only team you’ll ever need. Sharing the mindset of a client-centric business, our agents at Best Flagstaff Homes Realty focus on making our clients our top priority – putting the client’s needs before all else, and ensuring that every transaction is one that our clients can look back on fondly. We know that buying and selling a home can be a stressful process and we do our best to alleviate that as much as possible. The Best Flagstaff Homes Realty team has a combined 100 years of experience! We have seen different markets and have learned to navigate through all of them. We do this with expertise, knowledge, great skill and care, and a lot of laughter. We will listen to your needs and make the process fun along the way. With the integrity you expect, the expertise you depend upon, and the compassion you deserve, Best Flagstaff Homes Realty is the real estate team you’ve been looking for. We would love to work with you.

Flagstaff’s Premier Real Estate Team

Best Flagstaff Homes Realty


“The whole is greater than the sum of it’s parts”- Aristotle


Nothing could be more true in the real estate profession. As individual agents, Sara Holloway, Kelly Kasprzyk, Tad Moore, and Cody Bauer have built their real estate business by striving to provide their clients with an optimal client experience. But no one agent can do it alone.


Through their combined expertise, knowledge and work ethic, Sara, Kelly, Tad, and Cody can now bring the client experience to an entirely new level!


No market is too challenging. No obstacle can’t be overcome. Not with The Foundation Group in your corner. Because every home and every relationship begins with a solid foundation.

Meet the Foundation Group at Best Flagstaff Homes Realty:

CODY Bauer

REALTOR® Cody Bauer grew up in Iowa, where he developed a strong work ethic and a deep appreciation for community values. These core principles continue to drive him today as he assists individuals and families in finding their perfect homes in Flagstaff and the surrounding areas. With a diverse background spanning small boutique brokerages, large office settings, and corporate real estate, bringing a unique perspective and a wealth of knowledge to every transaction.

When Cody isn’t assisting clients, he enjoys traveling and experiencing new places, exploring Flagstaff’s scenic beauty, hiking its breathtaking trails, or engaging with the vibrant local community. His love for the area shines through in his commitment to helping others discover the unparalleled charm and exceptional lifestyle that Flagstaff and Northern Arizona have to offer.


 REALTOR® Sara Holloway grew up a REALTOR®’s daughter. Since the age of 8, she spent her weekends following her mother to showings, open houses and parade of homes. I guess you could say real estate runs in Sara’s blood.

Sara was born in Iowa and spent her childhood in Minnesota, and in 1999 she moved to Flagstaff. After over 20 years in Flagstaff, she considers herself a local. Prior to joining the Elite Team in 2016, Sara owned and operated a local restaurant/bar for many years before selling in 2013.

Sara has earned designations including Graduate, REALTOR® Institute and Accredited Buyer’s Agent®. One of Sara’s passions is serving her community, she has been a part of the Arizona Community Foundation as well as served  on the MLS committee for Northern Arizona’s Association of Realtors where she served as the MLS Chair in 2022. Sara’s passion, drive and determination will get you through any real estate transaction and will likely get you laughing a few times too. In her free time she loves traveling and boating Lake Powell with her 2 kids and Flagstaff native husband. She is a big time gym rat with a love for running, weight lifting and fitness in general.


REALTOR® Kelly Kasprzyk is a 1996 graduate of Northern Arizona University with a Bachelor’s degree in marketing and public relations. Kelly came to NAU from Wyoming on a university golf scholarship. She has been practicing real estate in the Arizona market since 2003.

Prior to real estate, Kelly was the Director of Fundraising and Event Coordination for the NAU Athletics Department. Kelly is a professional who enjoys matching her clients’ lifestyles with the perfect property. Kelly prepares everyone involved for what lies ahead, and she makes sure they understand each step and they look forward to the process. She has worked in and enjoys all areas of real estate, from first-time home buyers to her current expertise of luxury sales. With an emphasis on the private golf communities of Pine Canyon, Forest Highlands and Flagstaff Ranch. Kelly is an Accredited Buyer’s Representative® and has received the GUILD™ certification for luxury home sales. Kelly prides herself on having high confidentiality and discretion when dealing with clients.

In Kelly’s spare time, she enjoys volunteering and serves as the Vice President for the Skyjacks Foundation, the Arizona Community Foundation as well as the co-chair for the Northern Arizona ChildHelp chapter. In 2019 Kelly was selected as a board member for the Arizona Golf Association. When Kelly isn’t working with her clients or volunteering, you will find her hiking the mountains with her Bernese Mountain dog, Sierra, or playing a round of golf. Kelly is also the head cheerleader for local start-up companies Machine Solutions, Symple Surgical and POBA Medical.


REALTOR® Tad Moore began his real estate career in 2006. Being born and raised in Flagstaff, he has an intimate knowledge of Northern Arizona and is passionate about advising his clients on any real estate transaction they may need. Tad prides himself on being able to provide his clients with the expertise and guidance they deserve.

Tad also has earned designations as an Accredited Buyer’s Representative®, e-Pro®, Green Building Expert®, and is At Home With Diversity® Certified, as education allows him to serve his clients in the best possible way. Although the real estate transaction process can seem daunting, Tad strives to make every transaction as fun and stress-free as possible.

Being passionate about his community, Tad is involved with several local organizations including the Arizona Community Foundation of Flagstaff, the Northern Arizona Housing Fund, and has served in numerous roles with the Northern Arizona Association of REALTORS® including MLS Committee Chair, Advocacy Committee Chair, and President.

When not advising his clients, Tad enjoys spending time with his amazing wife, three children and two dogs, collecting Star Wars memorabilia and vintage comic books, mountain biking, weightlifting, and training in Shaolin Kung-Fu.


DESIGNATED BROKER for Best Flagstaff Homes. Jessica Garard is a Flagstaff native, an NAU graduate, and has always called Flagstaff home. She has loved her career as a REALTOR® since 2006, helping buyers and sellers navigate through the Flagstaff real estate market. Jessica and Eric teamed up in 2009 and formed a great team. She is excited to evolve that into the best locally owned brokerage in Flagstaff.

Jessica prides herself on being a knowledgeable, trustworthy source in the Flagstaff market. Her favorite parts of selling real estate are the lifelong relationships she has made. Jessica is a Designated Broker, Graduate, REALTOR® Institute, Accredited Buyer Representative®, and has been inducted as a member of the Master of Real Estate Society. She is currently the Vice President of Northern Arizona Association of REALTORS® and she is also a member of the Professional Standards Committee for the Arizona Association of REALTORS®.

Jessica enjoys exploring Flagstaff on the numerous running trails throughout town as “Flagstaff’s Running Realtor.” The rest of Jessica’s time is spent with her husband and son enjoying all that Northern Arizona has to offer.


Eric Davis is Co-Owner and Managing Broker for Best Flagstaff Homes Realty. He has lived his entire life in Flagstaff. He started his professional career working for New England Business Services, Inc. NEBS. During his 15 year career there Eric obtained his degree in Business Management and was a Corporate Trainer. Desiring a change, Eric made the decision to pursue real estate and obtained his license in November 2004. Together with Jessica Garard they formed Best Flagstaff Homes Realty in the summer of 2021. 

Eric is a Certified Negotiations Expert (CNE). He has developed a passion for navigating the ever changing world of real estate for his Buyers and Sellers.

His passions outside of real estate involve spending time with his wife, four kids and granddaughter. He is obsessed with riding his motorcycle, especially on the many scenic highways in Arizona, Utah and Colorado. He also enjoys camping, hunting, and fishing. And don’t get him started on his cast iron cookware collection.  

Volunteering is one of the many ways Eric loves to give back to his community. He was one of the first citizens to serve as a commissioner on the Housing Commission with the City of Flagstaff. He is very passionate about donating blood and sponsors four blood drives a year for Vitalant, the main supplier of blood for our mountain town.



Keith Cohen has been an active member of the community since relocating to Flagstaff from the Phoenix Valley, including organizing neighborhood food drives, providing assistance to our homeless population, and helping out with roadside garbage cleanup. He is so excited to be continuing this community focus via the real estate industry, helping our neighbors navigate the oftentimes-challenging market here in Flagstaff.

With a passion for service in the Flagstaff area, Keith is ready to help with your home buying and selling needs. As a proud member of the Best Flagstaff Homes Realty family, Keith carries the values of hard work, integrity, and outstanding client service into everything he does. His career work in the Customer Service / Relationship Management fields not only aids during a real estate transaction but fosters long-term friendships beyond the transaction.

When Keith isn’t making homeownership dreams come true for his clients, he enjoys spending time hiking the many Arizona trails, playing racquetball, and golfing. Keith currently resides in the Railroad Springs community with his wife and 2 young children.


Linda is a real estate entrepreneur and associate broker who is passionate about helping others achieve their real estate objectives – be it buying a first home, vacation home, or an investment property, or selling to upsize, downsize or relocate.

Her focus is not only on achieving the end objective but also on delivering an excellent experience. She is dedicated to ensuring each client gets the attention they deserve while developing long-term relationships that will outlast any single transaction.

Linda is an Accredited Buyer’s Representative (ABR®) and Master Certified Negotiation Expert (MCNE) with over 28 years of personal and professional real estate investing experience.

Linda also received her real estate Broker License in 2019 and holds the Certified New Home Specialist (CNHS) and Residential Construction Certified (RCC) designations which reflect her dedication to continuous improvement and education.


Marian Armstrong has been helping clients achieve their real estate goals for over 17 years as a REALTOR® in Northern Arizona and loves working with the team at Best Flagstaff Homes!

She has a long relationship with the Flagstaff area, moving here in the early 90’s and graduating from NAU with a marketing degree in 1997. After living, working, attending college, adventuring & raising a family in Flagstaff, Marian is a biased advocate of her mountain town. Helping others to relocate & call it home is her passion. She strives to listen to her client’s needs, get to know their stories, and provide them with a personalized, professional experience. She values long-term relationships and wants buyers and sellers to be able to count on her continued support and friendship well after the sale has closed.

Away from work, Marian may be found hiking Big Bang trail, meeting friends downtown for local eats, creating a colorful piece of collage art, or trying to catch up with her adventure-loving husband and three adult kids.


Arin is an Arizona native and long time Flagstaff resident and business owner. She moved to Northern Arizona in 1997 residing in both Flagstaff and Williams. She graduated Summa Cum Laude from NAU in 2005 with a degree in Biology and Psychology. Arin was an early childhood educator and preschool owner in Flagstaff from 2001-2020. After nearly twenty years of serving Flagstaff families and leading childhood adventures, Arin decided to make a career change and become a REALTOR®️️.

Arin is passionate about real estate and the power that home ownership brings to people, as well as its ability to be an incredible investment tool. After participating in numerous real estate transactions personally it was obvious that becoming a REALTOR ®️️ was an inevitable part of her future. Arin became a REALTOR ®️️ in 2021, and has had a driven and successful start. She is motivated to help people define and achieve their goals while providing exceptional service.

Arin was awarded “Rookie of The Year 2022” by the Northern Arizona Association of Realtors.  She serves on the MLS committee for Northern Arizona Association of Realtors  and is the co-chair for the Equity, Diversity and Inclusion committee.

When Arin is not working, she is playing hard. Arin has been a roller derby skater with High Altitude Roller Derby for nearly 7 years. Pre-pandemic she traveled the country competing, hitting hard, getting hit even harder, falling down and getting back up!. Outside of derby, she can be found on the mountain bike trails, cross country skiing, paddle boarding, camping, finding creatures in nature and just being outdoors with her family, friends and two French Bulldogs.

Best Flagstaff Homes Realty

120 N Beaver St., Suite 100
Flagstaff, AZ 86001

(928) 714-0001

[email protected]


Contact Best Flagstaff Homes Realty for all of your Real Estate needs!


"Jessica and the team were tremendous to work with. They made the process of selling our home simple and fluid. I would highly recommend this team to anyone looking for a knowledgeable team that knows the market."


"I have worked with many real estate brokers and agents on several real estate transact ions over the years and can say with confidence that Arin is the best agent. Arin has the qualities that make her an extremely successful and effective broker. I can’t say enough about her professionalism and knowledge within the industry. She has high integrity and is very conscientious and tenacious, always keeping the client’s best interests in mind. Our real estate sale was extremely complicated due to the advanced ages of my Uncle and Aunt. Her empathy and focus was instrumental in executing the transfer of ownership. One of the qualities I respected the most was her willingness to roll up her sleeves and get the job done."

–George A. McGuire

"I usually don't do reviews, but Kelly has done such an outstanding job for me for several years now. I bought my first property with Kelly in 2005. She was patient and professional. She took the time to show me several properties at various price points in several areas. Once I found "the one", we wrote up an offer immediately. I still own that home and have since bought 4 additional properties with Kelly. I sold one of those with Kelly. We got the price I wanted. I will use Kelly any time I wish to do business in Flagstaff!"


"When we were relocating to Flagstaff , it was suggested that we contact Kelly Kasprzyk and we were so fortunate to have her as our real estate agent. Kelly is not only energetic and a joy to work with, she worked tirelessly and patiently to help us find the perfect Flagstaff home for our specific needs in this new locale. She not only knows this market and details of all neighborhoods in Flag, she was also extremely helpful during all parts of the process with offering through closure and then our move in. We couldn't be happier with the results."


"We had a wonderful experience buying our home with Tad Moore. He is patient and full of knowledge. He guides us through the process and helped us make some very tough negotiations. We felt lucky to have him our corner and fighting for us. Best experience by far in purchasing a home and this will be our third. I highly recommend Tad to anyone buying a home, he is a fantastic agent!!! He will go the extra mile and then some!"


"Tad is a dream to work with. He bears the perfect balance of personality and professionalism. Additionally, he brings a wealth of experience and knowledge to the table and never makes you feel like a burden when you have a lot of questions. His instincts are spot on, and he puts a lot of time and effort into getting to know his clients likes and dislikes so he can guide them to their dream home. I highly recommend him!"


"We can't even begin to explain how wonderful [Best Flagstaff Homes Realty] has been! The moment we met Sara and Jessica, and later Eric, we were beyond impressed. The team's communication and hard work ethic is unmatched. and I strongly believe their " Team Concept" is one of the reasons why this particular realty group is and will continue to be so successful. We honestly can't say enough good things about Sara, Jessica and Eric because truthfully, they went way above our expectations, and we are so incredibly grateful!"


"Eric Davis was recommended by a friend who had had a good experience with him. He was very patient with us over a long period of time always easy to reach and prompt in returning our calls. We never felt like he was just trying to "make a sale" but was looking for the right home for us, and indeed, he found that home. Would recommend him highly."


"I love working with Jessica! She was there for me when I first bought my home and when I sold it to relocate. Both Jessica and Eric were great and available to help me when I needed it and I felt supported, especially during the selling process. They took something that was very scary for me and made it such an easy and painless process. I continue to recommend them to my friends in the area and highly recommend them to anyone reading this."


"Working with Jessica and Eric were extremely helpful in helping me get the perfect house. I always felt they were working for me and not just out to make a sale. Jessica returned my calls promptly and arranged viewings quickly, which is important in the Flagstaff market. I would recommend them to anyone needing help finding a home."


"Let’s put it this way: I would not buy or sell a home without Marian Armstrong. Best realtor in Flagstaff. She loves and knows Flagstaff like nobody else, she’s ridiculously savvy about helping you find the perfect fit, expertly guiding you through the maze of home buying and selling. That expertise is even more essential now than ever. She takes the time to get to know her clients and goes above and beyond for each and every one of them. If I could give her 6 stars I would! I’ve also had the pleasure of collaborating with her colleagues at Best Flagstaff Homes and can tell you that they are an amazing, fun group with a wealth of local knowledge. A great resource in our town."


"Can’t say enough good things about Jessica Garard and the team at Best Flagstaff Homes Realty... As Flagstaff natives, nobody knows the town and the market better. Jessica is professional, down to earth, accessible and so easy to communicate with. She helped us key in on our favorite neighborhoods and then navigate an extremely competitive sellers market. Through her network, we were able to get a first opportunity and capitalize on an amazing house with forest access. Jessica coached us every step of the way from making an offer, getting under contract, navigating inspections and then closing. She had professionals at her fingertips for every need that arose."


"Eric Davis is an *amazing* agent. He walked us around a bunch of properties virtually before we arrived in town, and then helped us get a fantastic home that we love (not an easy task in this insane market). And what's more, he's been there every step of the way to help us find local handymen, remodelers, etc. He knows pretty much everyone in Flagstaff, and he's more than happy to help out. Also, to boot, he's one of the nicest people we've ever met. Can't recommend him and his agency highly enough."


"I loved working with Kelly Kasprzyk on our home sale. She is well-connected with the community and generous with her referrals to professionals to help us get ready. She was a great educator about the process of buying/selling in Flagstaff. Would highly recommend!"


"Marian Armstrong is amazing. She goes so far above and beyond she is in another galaxy from other agents. She is professional and yet exudes a warmth that makes you wish your deal wouldn’t close so you could spend more time with her. I recommend her to all my close friends as I know she will take good care of them."


"Tad was awesome to work with! His knowledge of Flagstaff real estate and insight on the market proved to be invaluable in navigating a very competitive market. He was also extremely helpful and detailed in pointing out features/sharing his perspectives during our video showings which made us feel comfortable when we ultimately made an offer...which was accepted (woot- thanks, Tad!)! We just closed on our house & Tad is going above & beyond expectations by continuing to assist us with some logistical coordination w/local utilities as we are currently out of state. We highly recommend Tad!"


"Jessica and her team are amazing. She is an excellent communicator, responds quickly and she knows how to get a deal done. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell real estate."


"Sara was very professional, personable, a good listener, and extremely responsive. She turned what could have easily been a stressful and frustrating endeavor into a pleasurable experience."


"We bought our first home with Sara at Elite Team, the whole experience was wonderful so naturally we returned to her for the purchase of our second home. She couldn’t have done a better job for us! It all fell together so seamlessly because of Sara’s hard work. She found us a house that checked all our boxes plus some! It’s a home for our family. A sanctuary. We are so thankful for her knowledge and her determination to find us an incredible forever home. Thank you Sara and Elite Team for the dedication you show all your clients and this community!"


"We recently purchased our home with the assistance of agent Kelly Kasprzyk and we couldn’t imagine having done it without her. We were first time home buyers and her experience and professionalism was crucial in closing our deal. If you are looking for an agent that will go above and beyond, you need to give Kelly a call. Kelly, thank you so much for all you have done for us!"


Skip to content